Season: Combine the burger seasoning ingredients in a small bowl. Place the patties on a sheet pan and sprinkle a pinch of seasoning on each one.
Heat Grill: Heat the Ninja Foodi Grill to 375F and the Woodfire Grill to medium.
Grill: Place the patties on the grill seasoned side down. Sprinkle more rub on top. Grill for five minutes with the hood closed. Flip. Grill for five more minutes.
Add Cheese: Place a slice of cheese on each patty and let it melt for 30-60 seconds. Remove the patties from the grill.
Assemble: Place each patty on a bun and top with your favorite condiments.
Notes
You can substitute the American cheese with cheddar or pepper jack cheese. Or omit the cheese all together.